The (only) three ways to improve performance in schools
Richard Elmore pinpoints fundamental tensions between district-based efforts for systemic improvement and the performance-based accountability demands of No Child Left Behind. "We have gotten ourselves into a situation where testing has become the primary lever of accountability and improvement," Elmore says. He cites significant consequences that interfere with our efforts to bring about instructional change:
"These issues don't actually compromise or demean performance-base accountability," states Elmore. "They just pose problems for it – and they're not getting treated as issues of public accountability."
Elmore cautions districts as they wrestle with creating instructional change in this climate, "If you don't have a way of connecting instruction to management, organization, and accountability, you're behaving irresponsibly." He advises focusing on those things that make the instructional core work.
What this means, says Elmore, is there are basically only three ways you can increase learning and performance:
"The instructional core helps us identify where we're trying to improve," explains Elmore. "The teacher, the student, the content – if you change one, you have to change them all." He elaborates:
"You can't alter the skill and knowledge of the teacher when you stay in a low-level curriculum. If you alter the content without changing the skill and knowledge of teachers, you are asking teachers to teach to a level that they don't have the skill and knowledge to teach to. If you do either one of those things without changing the role of the student in the instructional process, the likelihood that students will ever take control of their own learning is pretty remote."
Given the serious consequences of the current accountability context, Elmore advocates focusing on the instructional core in schools – the teacher and the student in the presence of content. He cautions districts and policy makers, "If you push on an organization and you don't have a theory about how it shows up in teaching and learning, you're basically causing people to do rain dances."
For more than 25 years, the Harvard Graduate School of Education has offered professional education programs for educational leaders. We are committed to offering programs that make a difference — in the lives of students, in the work of institutions, and in the practice of educators.
Visit www.hgse.harvard.edu/ppe for a complete listing of upcoming professional development offerings with Harvard faculty.